Patriot Isn’t a Silver Bullet for Ukraine Air Defense, Officials Say

  • The US announced on Wednesday that it would provide Ukraine with a Patriot air-defense system.
  • The Patriot is seen as a vital weapon to counter Russia’s attacks with missiles and aircraft.
  • The Patriot system is highly capable, but officials caution that there’s only so much it can do.

The US announced on Wednesday that it was sending a Patriot missile-defense battery to Ukraine, fulfilling a longstanding request from Kyiv to counter ongoing attacks by Russian aircraft and missiles.

The Patriot is considered one of the most capable long-range air-defense systems in service and as vital to defending Ukraine’s military and civilians, but officials and experts caution that there is only so much the Patriot itself can do to fend off that aerial assault .

The Patriot battery and accompanying munitions are part of a $1 billion package announced on Wednesday as a presidential drawdown, meaning its contents will be pulled directly from US stocks. It is only the latest air-defense weapon that the US has committed to Ukraine. Washington has previously pledged to send National Advanced Surface-to-Air Missile Systems, Hawk air-defense systems, and Avenger air-defense systems.

While the decision to send the Patriot to Ukraine is a milestone, it will be some time before it is in use in Ukraine. A senior US defense official told reporters on Wednesday that there is not “a precise date” for when the battery would be transferred and acknowledged that there would be “a several-month training process.”

A Patriot missile system in Germany

A Bundeswehr combat-ready Patriot missile system at a military airport in Germany on March 17.

Axel Heimken/picture alliance via Getty Images



Training ranges from 13 weeks for the Patriot launch-system operator to 53 weeks for the system repairer. Ukraine could speed that up by sending troops who are trained on its other air-defense systems, but the US official said Wednesday that how many would be trained and where they would be trained was still undetermined.

“The training will begin very soon, and again, it will take several months, and the training is the limiting timeframe here,” the official said. “The Ukrainians will have to complete the training in order to be able to field the system, and it’s the Ukrainians who are operating the system, so that’s absolutely essential.”

A Patriot battery typically has eight launchers, each capable of firing four to 16 interceptor missiles depending on the type being used. Each battery has support equipment, like a radar system and a power supply, and is staffed by about 90 troops, though only three are needed to operate it once deployed.

Patriot interceptors have operational ranges from a few dozen miles to roughly 100 miles and can reach altitudes of about 80,000 feet. The interceptors can be used against a variety of targets, including cruise missiles, aircraft, and drones, but are not cheap, costing a few million dollars each.

US officials have raised concerns about using Patriot interceptors against the relatively cheap drones that have proliferated on battlefields around the world, including in Ukraine.

“The high cost per missile and the relatively small number of missiles in a battery means that Patriot operators cannot shoot at every target,” according to Mark Cancian and Tom Karako, military experts at the Center for Strategic and International Studies.

Japan soldiers Patriot missiles

Japan soldiers set up Patriot missiles at the Defense Ministry in Tokyo in April 2012.

JIJI PRESS/AFP/GettyImages



“High-value Russian aircraft and ballistic missiles would be appropriate targets. Shooting $4 million missiles at $250,000 Russian cruise missiles might be justified if those missiles would hit sensitive targets. Shooting a $4 million missile at a $50,000 Iranian Shahed-136 drone would probably not ,” Cancian and Karako wrote this week.

Officials speaking on Wednesday declined to discuss how Ukraine would employ the Patriot system but stressed that it was meant to be part of a larger air-defense network.

“There is no silver bullet. Our goal is to help Ukraine strengthen a layered, integrated approach to air defense that will include Ukraine’s own legacy capabilities as well as NATO-standard systems,” the senior defense official said. “Patriot will complement a range of medium- and short-range air-defense capabilities” that have been provided by the US and its allies.

While the Patriot battery would cover a small area and is suited for a limited range of targets, it does have value as a signal of US commitment to Ukraine, Cancian and Karako wrote.

Speaking alongside President Joe Biden on Wednesday, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy welcomed the Patriot, calling it “the strongest element of this package” and “something that will strengthen our air defense significantly.”

“This is a very important step to create secure airspace for Ukraine, and that’s the only way we would be able to deprive the terrorist country of their terror attack to strike our energy sector, our people, and our infrastructure,” Zelenskyy said, speaking through a translator.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *